Monday Afternoon Pairs Monday Aft Session November 3, 2014 Scores after 10 rounds Average: 90.0 Section A North-South Pair Pct Score Section Rank MPs A B C 5 60.68 109.22 B 1 1 0.88(A) Dan Benson - Vince Grassi 9 60.09 108.17 B 2 2 0.62(A) Judy Hartman - Berna Sherman 8 58.61 105.50 B 3 3 0.44(A) Sara Gainey - Joseph Kovach 2 58.18 104.72 A 4 0.31(A) Marlene Winkleman - Sue Wessner 11 52.93 95.28 A Phyllis Wintz - Lee Ernst 6 49.29 88.72 A Leacy Wahl - Brian Snyder 10 47.19 84.94 A Raquel Yiengst - Richard Yiengst 3 43.64 78.56 C 1 0.15(C) Kathy Esterly - Candis Siatkowski 4 41.63 74.94 B Joan Scribner - Ludwig Schmidbauer 7 41.01 73.82 C Romaine Schwartz - Diann Hayes 1 36.08 64.94 C Lynda Thaler - Lee Seckinger Monday Afternoon Pairs Monday Aft Session November 3, 2014 Scores after 10 rounds Average: 90.0 Section A East-West Pair Pct Score Section Rank MPs A B C 4 64.01 115.22 A 1 0.88(A) Lucia Di Paolo - Jack Berry 7 63.16 113.68 A 2 0.62(A) Gail Weimer - Carl Ziegler 11 60.46 108.83 A 3 0.44(A) Theresa Althouse - Ralph Althouse 10 53.02 95.44 B 4 1 0.64(B) Beth Jasinski - Linda Snyder 6 47.26 85.06 C 2 1 0.45(B) Maureen Brumbach - Suzanne Storck 9 46.11 83.00 C 3 2 0.32(B) Ruth Morelli - Jewel Albright 8 45.71 82.28 C Barbara Swales - Thomas Swales 1 45.59 82.06 B Diana Mulligan - Gloria Kintzer 2 45.59 82.06 C Mary McSurdy - Barbara Logero 5 41.27 74.28 C Barbara Bender - Marjorie Shearer 3 38.49 69.28 B Marcia Eligman - Jan Maniar RESULTS OF BOARD 1 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 420 1.50 7.50 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 50 7.50 1.50 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 5-Bender-Shearer 420 1.50 7.50 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler 50 7.50 1.50 5-Benson-Grassi vs 9-Morelli-Albright 250 3.00 6.00 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 11-Althouse-Althouse 90 6.00 3.00 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 2-McSurdy-Logero 450 0.00 9.00 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry 100 9.00 0.00 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 6-Brumbach-Storck 200 4.00 5.00 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 8-Swales-Swales 170 5.00 4.00 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 2 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 50 3.00 6.00 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 300 9.00 0.00 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 5-Bender-Shearer 100 1.00 8.00 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler 130 8.00 1.00 5-Benson-Grassi vs 9-Morelli-Albright 90 4.00 5.00 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 11-Althouse-Althouse 100 1.00 8.00 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 2-McSurdy-Logero 100 1.00 8.00 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry 110 6.00 3.00 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 6-Brumbach-Storck 110 6.00 3.00 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 8-Swales-Swales 110 6.00 3.00 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 3 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 100 5.50 3.50 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 11-Althouse-Althouse 200 8.00 1.00 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 2-McSurdy-Logero 150 2.00 7.00 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 6-Brumbach-Storck 100 5.50 3.50 5-Benson-Grassi vs 8-Swales-Swales 100 5.50 3.50 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder 650 0.00 9.00 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 100 5.50 3.50 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 3-Eligman-Maniar 300 9.00 0.00 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 5-Bender-Shearer 200 1.00 8.00 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler 90 3.00 6.00 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 9-Morelli-Albright ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 4 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 80 3.00 6.00 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 11-Althouse-Althouse 400 9.00 0.00 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 2-McSurdy-Logero 80 3.00 6.00 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 6-Brumbach-Storck 90 5.00 4.00 5-Benson-Grassi vs 8-Swales-Swales 80 3.00 6.00 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder 200 7.50 1.50 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 100 6.00 3.00 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 3-Eligman-Maniar 200 7.50 1.50 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 5-Bender-Shearer 100 0.50 8.50 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler 100 0.50 8.50 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 9-Morelli-Albright ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 5 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 100 0.50 8.50 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder 100 0.50 8.50 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 110 2.50 6.50 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 3-Eligman-Maniar 630 8.00 1.00 5-Benson-Grassi vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler 130 5.00 4.00 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 9-Morelli-Albright 110 2.50 6.50 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 11-Althouse-Althouse 630 8.00 1.00 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 2-McSurdy-Logero 130 5.00 4.00 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry 130 5.00 4.00 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 6-Brumbach-Storck 630 8.00 1.00 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 8-Swales-Swales ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 6 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 150 2.00 7.00 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder 400 6.00 3.00 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 430 9.00 0.00 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 3-Eligman-Maniar 130 0.00 9.00 5-Benson-Grassi vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler 400 6.00 3.00 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 9-Morelli-Albright 400 6.00 3.00 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 11-Althouse-Althouse 150 2.00 7.00 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 2-McSurdy-Logero 400 6.00 3.00 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry 150 2.00 7.00 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 6-Brumbach-Storck 400 6.00 3.00 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 8-Swales-Swales ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 7 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 90 6.00 3.00 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 9-Morelli-Albright 300 0.00 9.00 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 11-Althouse-Althouse 110 3.00 6.00 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 2-McSurdy-Logero 110 3.00 6.00 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry 200 1.00 8.00 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 8-Swales-Swales 400 9.00 0.00 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder 90 6.00 3.00 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 110 3.00 6.00 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 3-Eligman-Maniar 100 8.00 1.00 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 5-Bender-Shearer 90 6.00 3.00 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 8 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 450 4.50 4.50 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 9-Morelli-Albright 450 4.50 4.50 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 11-Althouse-Althouse 200 0.50 8.50 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 2-McSurdy-Logero 450 4.50 4.50 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry 450 4.50 4.50 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 8-Swales-Swales 450 4.50 4.50 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder 480 8.50 0.50 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 480 8.50 0.50 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 3-Eligman-Maniar 200 0.50 8.50 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 5-Bender-Shearer 450 4.50 4.50 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 9 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 90 4.50 4.50 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 8-Swales-Swales 90 4.50 4.50 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder 200 8.50 0.50 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 200 8.50 0.50 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 3-Eligman-Maniar 100 7.00 2.00 5-Benson-Grassi vs 5-Bender-Shearer 110 1.00 8.00 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 9-Morelli-Albright 90 4.50 4.50 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 11-Althouse-Althouse 90 4.50 4.50 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 2-McSurdy-Logero 110 1.00 8.00 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry 110 1.00 8.00 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 6-Brumbach-Storck ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 10 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 150 3.00 6.00 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 8-Swales-Swales 620 0.00 9.00 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder 170 1.50 7.50 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 300 9.00 0.00 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 3-Eligman-Maniar 170 1.50 7.50 5-Benson-Grassi vs 5-Bender-Shearer 110 6.50 2.50 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 9-Morelli-Albright PASS 8.00 1.00 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 11-Althouse-Althouse 140 4.50 4.50 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 2-McSurdy-Logero 110 6.50 2.50 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry 140 4.50 4.50 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 6-Brumbach-Storck ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 11 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 80 1.50 7.50 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler 120 8.50 0.50 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 9-Morelli-Albright 110 0.00 9.00 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 11-Althouse-Althouse PASS 3.00 6.00 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 2-McSurdy-Logero 80 1.50 7.50 5-Benson-Grassi vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry 50 5.00 4.00 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 6-Brumbach-Storck 50 5.00 4.00 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder 50 5.00 4.00 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 120 8.50 0.50 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 3-Eligman-Maniar 110 7.00 2.00 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 5-Bender-Shearer ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 12 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 490 0.50 8.50 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler 50 8.50 0.50 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 9-Morelli-Albright 130 6.50 2.50 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 11-Althouse-Althouse 130 6.50 2.50 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 2-McSurdy-Logero 490 0.50 8.50 5-Benson-Grassi vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry 400 2.00 7.00 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 6-Brumbach-Storck 150 4.50 4.50 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder 50 8.50 0.50 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 150 4.50 4.50 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 3-Eligman-Maniar 170 3.00 6.00 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 5-Bender-Shearer ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 13 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 130 3.94 5.06 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 6-Brumbach-Storck 170 6.72 2.28 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 8-Swales-Swales 140 0.06 8.94 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder 130 3.94 5.06 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 170 6.72 2.28 5-Benson-Grassi vs 3-Eligman-Maniar 170 6.72 2.28 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 5-Bender-Shearer AVE- AVE+ 3.32 5.68 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler 110 1.17 7.83 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 11-Althouse-Althouse 210 8.94 0.06 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 2-McSurdy-Logero 120 2.28 6.72 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 14 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 150 7.50 1.50 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 6-Brumbach-Storck 300 9.00 0.00 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 8-Swales-Swales 90 4.00 5.00 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder 50 5.00 4.00 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 100 2.50 6.50 5-Benson-Grassi vs 3-Eligman-Maniar 150 7.50 1.50 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 5-Bender-Shearer 100 2.50 6.50 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler 150 0.50 8.50 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 11-Althouse-Althouse 150 0.50 8.50 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 2-McSurdy-Logero 90 6.00 3.00 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 15 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 170 3.50 5.50 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 5-Bender-Shearer 170 3.50 5.50 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler 170 3.50 5.50 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 9-Morelli-Albright 450 0.00 9.00 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 11-Althouse-Althouse 620 9.00 0.00 5-Benson-Grassi vs 2-McSurdy-Logero 50 7.00 2.00 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry 50 7.00 2.00 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 6-Brumbach-Storck 170 3.50 5.50 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 8-Swales-Swales 420 1.00 8.00 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 50 7.00 2.00 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 3-Eligman-Maniar ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 16 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 140 5.00 4.00 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 5-Bender-Shearer 200 6.00 3.00 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler 130 3.00 6.00 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 9-Morelli-Albright 50 1.00 8.00 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 11-Althouse-Althouse 450 9.00 0.00 5-Benson-Grassi vs 2-McSurdy-Logero 130 3.00 6.00 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry 100 0.00 9.00 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 6-Brumbach-Storck 130 3.00 6.00 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 8-Swales-Swales 400 7.00 2.00 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 430 8.00 1.00 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 3-Eligman-Maniar ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 17 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 400 4.00 5.00 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry 430 7.00 2.00 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 6-Brumbach-Storck 180 2.00 7.00 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 8-Swales-Swales 400 4.00 5.00 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder 460 9.00 0.00 5-Benson-Grassi vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 430 7.00 2.00 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 3-Eligman-Maniar 90 1.00 8.00 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 5-Bender-Shearer 430 7.00 2.00 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler 400 4.00 5.00 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 9-Morelli-Albright 100 0.00 9.00 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 2-McSurdy-Logero ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 18 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 100 1.50 7.50 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry 660 9.00 0.00 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 6-Brumbach-Storck 600 6.50 2.50 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 8-Swales-Swales 600 6.50 2.50 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder 600 6.50 2.50 5-Benson-Grassi vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 100 1.50 7.50 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 3-Eligman-Maniar 100 1.50 7.50 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 5-Bender-Shearer 150 4.00 5.00 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler 100 1.50 7.50 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 9-Morelli-Albright 600 6.50 2.50 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 2-McSurdy-Logero ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 19 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 650 2.50 6.50 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 3-Eligman-Maniar 650 2.50 6.50 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 5-Bender-Shearer 650 2.50 6.50 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler 170 8.50 0.50 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 9-Morelli-Albright 650 2.50 6.50 5-Benson-Grassi vs 11-Althouse-Althouse 200 6.50 2.50 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 2-McSurdy-Logero 650 2.50 6.50 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry 170 8.50 0.50 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 6-Brumbach-Storck 200 6.50 2.50 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 8-Swales-Swales 650 2.50 6.50 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 20 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 100 1.50 7.50 1-Thaler-Seckinger vs 3-Eligman-Maniar 90 5.00 4.00 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 5-Bender-Shearer PASS 4.00 5.00 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler 200 0.00 9.00 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 9-Morelli-Albright 110 7.50 1.50 5-Benson-Grassi vs 11-Althouse-Althouse 100 1.50 7.50 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 2-McSurdy-Logero 90 3.00 6.00 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry 110 7.50 1.50 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 6-Brumbach-Storck 140 9.00 0.00 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 8-Swales-Swales 100 6.00 3.00 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 21 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 450 4.00 5.00 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry 450 4.00 5.00 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 6-Brumbach-Storck 450 4.00 5.00 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 8-Swales-Swales 450 4.00 5.00 5-Benson-Grassi vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder 450 4.00 5.00 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 450 4.00 5.00 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 3-Eligman-Maniar 450 4.00 5.00 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 5-Bender-Shearer 450 4.00 5.00 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler 200 9.00 0.00 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 9-Morelli-Albright 450 4.00 5.00 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 11-Althouse-Althouse ---------------------------------------------------------------------- RESULTS OF BOARD 22 SCORES MATCHPOINTS NAMES N-S E-W N-S E-W 100 2.50 6.50 2-Winkleman-Wessner vs 4-Di Paolo-Berry 200 1.00 8.00 3-Esterly-Siatkowski vs 6-Brumbach-Storck 650 0.00 9.00 4-Scribner-Schmidbauer vs 8-Swales-Swales 140 8.00 1.00 5-Benson-Grassi vs 10-Jasinski-Snyder 50 5.00 4.00 6-Wahl-Snyder vs 1-Mulligan-Kintzer 50 5.00 4.00 7-Schwartz-Hayes vs 3-Eligman-Maniar 420 9.00 0.00 8-Gainey-Kovach vs 5-Bender-Shearer 50 5.00 4.00 9-Hartman-Sherman vs 7-Weimer-Ziegler 100 2.50 6.50 10-Yiengst-Yiengst vs 9-Morelli-Albright 110 7.00 2.00 11-Wintz-Ernst vs 11-Althouse-Althouse ----------------------------------------------------------------------